Most preachers ask two questions when they consider a tool like this: Am I outsourcing my calling? and Is my sermon safe? This page answers both.
The short answer to the question of outsourcing your calling: No. The Sermon Coach evaluates a sermon you've already written. It doesn't study for you, write for you, or pray for you. The pulpit is still yours, and the work of getting there is still yours. The rubric is a trusted reader after the fact — not a co-author, not a ghostwriter, not a stand-in for the slow, prayerful, Spirit-driven work of sermon prep.
The short answer to the question of safety: Yes. Your sermons are yours — your study, your prayer, your work for your congregation — and The Sermon Coach is built to keep it that way.
Here's what that means in practice:
Your sermons stay private to your account. No other user can see them. In a Classroom, your instructor can read your evaluations — that oversight is the point of the tier — but your classmates never can. Everywhere else, private by default.
Your sermons are never used to train AI models. The Sermon Coach uses Anthropic's Claude API under data privacy terms that prohibit using your inputs for model training. Your preaching stays your preaching.
Your sermons are never shared or sold. We don't sell your data. We don't share your manuscripts with third parties. The only services that touch your sermon text are the ones required to deliver your evaluation — and they're listed in our Privacy Policy.
You stay in control. You can request deletion of any evaluation, or your entire account, at any time — just email Chris and we'll permanently delete it within 48 hours. Deletion is permanent. Your library is yours. Ask anytime and we'll send you everything you've submitted.
Built by a pastor, for pastors. We use the rubric on our own sermons too. If you ever have a question about how your data is handled — or about how the tool fits in your week of sermon prep — email Chris directly. He reads every email.
Every evaluation has two halves. The rubric scores your sermon against 11 criteria and tells you whether it is faithful: is the text driving, is the gospel clear, does the application land on a real person's Monday. How It Preaches is the second half. It sets the scoring aside and reads your sermon the way it plays for the person in the pew, walking the five movements every sermon moves through: the open, the big idea, the structural logic, the illustrations, and the landing.
It is a craft read, not a scorecard. No numbers, no bands. Just an honest paragraph on each movement: where the sermon grips, where it goes slack, whether an illustration earns its place or stalls the momentum, whether the ending arrives or just stops. It reads for what you were going for before it tells you whether you got there, and it names the real weak spots without inventing problems that aren't on the page.
The rubric tells you whether the sermon is faithful. How It Preaches tells you whether it lands. Two reads of one sermon, so you walk up to preach knowing both.